What is Art?

Author's Deep Dive Reveals Absurdities of NYC's Contemporary Art Scene

By Mel Laytner


What is art?

Journalist Bianca Bosker tackled this question head-on, or more accurately, head-first, diving deep and emerging with "Get the Picture," a rollicking expose of New York’s contemporary art scene.


With sharp humor and sharper insights, Bosker shared her experiences in a wide-ranging conversation with the Silurians own  Betsy Ashton, herself a successful artist, at the club’s Feb. 19 luncheon, catered, perhaps ironically, by the National Art Club.


“For most of my adult life, art and I were not on speaking terms,” Bosker said. Wandering through galleries and museums, she recalled she felt “at least two tattoos and a master’s degree away from figuring out” what she was seeing.


This led her to withdraw from art entirely, a retreat she now calls “the coward’s way out.”


A turning point came in the family attic with the discovery of paintings of “dancing carrots” by her late grandmother, a Holocaust survivor, created for children in a displaced persons camp after the war.

Bosker’s book – the full title is "Get the Picture: A Mind-Bending Journey among the Inspired Artists and Obsessive Art Fiends Who Taught Me How to See"  was a New York Times instant bestseller and named one of the Best Books of 2024 by NPR, Time, and The Economist.

The cover of the book get the picture by bianca bosker

Bosker’s book – the full title is "Get the Picture: A Mind-Bending Journey among the Inspired Artists and Obsessive Art Fiends Who Taught Me How to See"  was an instant New York Times Bestseller and named one of the Best Books of 2024 by NPR, Time, and The Economist.

Click to register   -  Wednesday, Mar. 19

In 2025, Our Profession is Being Challenged Like Never Before. 

A combination of new political threats to press freedom, collapsing business models and rapidly advancing AI is jeopardizing the essential elements of fearless reporting that have made America's news media the envy of the world. 

Our March 19 luncheon will feature three of the most incisive observers of the news media today — Brian Stelter, Oliver Darcy and Sewell Chan who hopefully will help find answers to a key question: What can we do about it? 

Click to Register [Members Only] Wednesday, Mar. 19

Brian Stelter  is the chief media analyst for CNN Worldwide and the lead author of the Reliable Sources newsletter.

He is also host of Vanity Fair’s weekly podcast,  Inside the Hive, and author of three books, most recently  “Network of Lies,” which examined Dominion’s blockbuster defamation case against Fox News.

The Wall Street Journal has declared  Oliver Darcy's new independent newsletter, Status, a "must-read" for anyone who wants insight into what's happening inside the news media.

Status  prides itself for its "scoop-driven reporting and sharp-edged analysis."  Darcy covers everything from Silicon Valley to presidential politics, aiming to connect the dots in a fragmented and fast moving media landscape.

Sewell Chan is the new executive editor of the Columbia Journalism Review.  Previously, Chan was editor in chief of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit newsroom based in Austin.

During his tenure the Tribune won the National Magazine Award and the Collier Prize for State Government Accountability and was a Pulitzer Prize finalist.

Click to Register [Members Only] Wednesday, Mar. 19

Judge Orders Mississippi Newspaper to Remove Editorial

Owner of The Clarksdale Press Register plans to challenge judge’s order against an editorial that criticized city officials.


Click for NY Times Story (paywall)
The logo for the ap is black and red on a white background.

AP sues Trump administration, citing freedom of speech

The AP says case about an unconstitutional effort to control speech — in this case not changing its style from the Gulf of Mexico to the “Gulf of America."

Click for AP Story

Many Americans don’t trust the media to cover Trump: Survey

YouGov poll (2/21) found 67% of U.S. respondents said that they don’t have “very much” or any trust that news outlets can state facts fairly, accurately and fully while covering Trump’s second term.

Click for The Hill Article

Fla. Appeals Court Rules Trump Can Pursue Suit Against Pulitzer Board

Dispute rooted in Pulitzer Prize to NY Times and Wash Post for reporting about alleged Russian interference in the 2016 election.


Read Miami Herald Story

Judge Orders Mississippi Newspaper to Remove Editorial

Owner of The Clarksdale Press Register plans to challenge judge’s order against an editorial that criticized city officials.


Click for NY Times Story (paywall)

AP sues Trump administration, citing freedom of speech

The AP says case about an unconstitutional effort to control speech — in this case not changing its style from the Gulf of Mexico to the “Gulf of America."

Click for AP Story

News Media News

White House removes liberal outlet from press pool rotation

The White House on Wednesday removed the Huffington Post, an outlet decried by the right as anti-Trump, from the pool of reporters granted close access to the president. The White House asked the Wall Street Journal to take the spot. It declined but Axios accepted.

Read Politico Story

WaPo Opinion Editor resigns after Jeff Bezos announces changes to Opinion section

The Washington Post's Opinion Section editor David Shipley resigned after owner Jeff Bezos mandated the section prioritize two topics, personal liberties and free markets, and not publish dissenting views in those areas.

Read Axios Story

AP again seeks end of its White House ban, saying the Trump administration is retaliating further

AP askes a federal judge for a second time to immediately restore its access to presidential events, arguing that the Trump White House has doubled down on retaliating against the news outlet for its refusal to follow the president’s executive order that renamed the Gulf of Mexico.

Read the AP Story

Des Moines Register Call For Dismissal Of Trump Lawsuit Over Iowa Poll

Lawyers for the Des Moines Register and Gannett argued that “there is no legal basis for President Trump to obtain the relief he seeks; indeed, such relief would violate free speech principles.”

Read HuffPost Story

Mississippi judge vacates order that newspaper remove its critical editorial

A Mississippi judge on Wednesday vacated her order that a newspaper remove its editorial criticizing local officials.


The judge’s order had been widely condemned by free speech advocates as a clear violation of the paper’s First Amendment rights.

Read the AP Story

Many Americans don’t trust the media to cover Trump: Survey

YouGov poll (2/21) found 67% of U.S. respondents said that they don’t have “very much” or any trust that news outlets can state facts fairly, accurately and fully while covering Trump’s second term.

Read The Hill Story

NY Times Publisher Outlines Possible Threats to Press Freedom Under Trump

By Mel Laytner


AG Sulzberger, the publisher of The New York Times,  issued a stark warning about the dangers that the incoming Trump administration could pose to press independence, describing methods used by authoritarian leaders worldwide to illustrate the risks.

Speaking to packed audience at the Silurians Press Club on Jan. 15, Sulzberger didn’t mince words.

“We’re in a period of prolonged and fairly intense democratic erosion,” he began, setting the stage for a critical conversation about the fragile state of press freedom.

A man is standing in front of two framed pictures on a wall.

Selwyn Raab (L) and actor Michael Imperioli serve as consulting producer and executive producer, respectively, for American Godfathers.

Selwyn Raab, The Don of Mafia Reporters 

Mafia chronicler to Best Selling author to Consulting Producer

By Joseph Berger

   When Selwyn Raab as growing up on the clamorous streets of the Lower East Side in the late 1930s and early 1940s, he learned that in the nearby neighborhood of Little Italy there was a group of men called “the Mafia,” whose scary members would sell you fun stuff like fireworks and pot.


Later in the 1960s as an education reporter writing about corrupt school-construction contracts, he was told by school officials that, if the city cracked down on the Mafia gangsters who were behind the corruption, the city would never get the fish it needed for student cafeterias. Nor would the schools’ garbage get picked up. 


 “Everywhere you looked, there was Mob involvement, and nobody was doing anything about it,” Raab said during a phone interview in September.

Continue Reading

A Silurian at the Met Museum of Art: Chester Higgins, Jr.

Award winning photographer's fascination with Egypt

By Roberta Hershenson

One of the hottest art shows  in town this winter was “Flight into Egypt: Black Artists and Ancient Egypt, 1876—Now,” which closed at the Metropolitan Museum of Art on Feb. 17. Critic Jason Farago, writing in the New York Times, called the show “winningly eclectic” and “beautifully designed,” while referring to Ancient Egypt as “an inspiration but also a lost dream” for the Black diaspora.

Continue Reading
A man is standing in front of two framed pictures on a wall.

Photo by Betsy Kissam

Chester Higgins, Jr., flanked by his two pieces in the Met’s “Flight Into Egypt” exhibit: “My two images help celebrate the African presence in the ancient Egyptian civilization.”

Recent Guests/Speakers

More Recent Silurian Speaker Videos

Recent Guests/Speakers

A gold coin that says the silurians press club new york

Applications Now Open for Silurians' 80th Excellence in Journalism Awards

  • We're the only awards program exclusively honoring local news coverage in the Metro area. 
  • Awards presented in 16 categories.
  • Entry deadline:midnight Monday March 10, 2025.
Click for complete contest rules and application.
Share by: